Where Exit Value Actually Gets Won or Lost

Table of Contents

Share this article on:

Authors:

ALEX McCall Profile Photo
Alex Mccall
caveat legal panel attorney john t
John Taylor
Lisa Brunton
caveat legal panel attorney nick b
Nick Bent
caveat legal panel attorney sarah lawrence
Sarah Lawrence
Simone Izzard
caveat legal panel attorney susan
Susan Braybrooke

Founders heading toward a sale, a fundraise, or a broader exit tend to focus on the negotiation. But by the time negotiation starts, most of the value has already been set — by how ready the business was before a buyer’s lawyers arrived.

Here’s where that value actually gets decided.

Due diligence tests whether the paper trail matches the story

Buyers are checking that what they’ve been told matches what’s on paper — clean ownership, resolved disputes, compliant contracts, no surprises buried in the financials. Deals most commonly stall or reprice over exactly the things founders assumed were minor: an unresolved dispute, an unsigned agreement, a share register that doesn’t match reality.

Warranties and indemnities are where undisclosed risk becomes priced risk

A warranty is a statement about the business that, if untrue, gives the buyer a claim; an indemnity is a specific promise to cover a named risk regardless of fault. A buyer who can’t get comfortable through warranties alone will typically price in a bigger holdback, or ask for warranty and indemnity insurance to bridge the gap — either way, the founder pays for the uncertainty one way or another.

Share sale versus asset sale sets the shape of the whole transaction

A share sale transfers the company as a whole, including its history and liabilities; an asset sale lets the buyer choose which assets and contracts to take on. Tax treatment, which liabilities you’re comfortable retaining, and what the buyer is actually willing to take on all shape which structure makes sense — and this decision needs to be made early, not defaulted into.

Deal timelines are set by readiness, not by negotiation

The biggest driver of how long a transaction takes from term sheet to completion is usually how prepared the target company was before diligence started. A business with clean housekeeping moves materially faster than one where the data room is being assembled from scratch mid-deal.

Owner-managed governance gets tested by exactly the same checks a buyer runs

Most governance guidance is written for listed companies, leaving owner-managed businesses without a clear standard to work to. In practice, it comes down to a small set of fundamentals — an accurate share register, signed resolutions for major decisions, a shareholders’ agreement everyone actually agrees on, and clarity on who needs to consent to what. Those are also the first things a buyer’s lawyers will check.

Employee share schemes built without an exit in mind complicate the exit

Vesting on exit, leaver provisions, and dilution all need to be resolved cleanly before or during the deal — not discovered mid-negotiation because the original scheme document didn’t anticipate a sale. If a scheme is running, it’s worth confirming the document actually addresses exit scenarios explicitly.

Franchise disclosure obligations are frequently treated as a formality when they aren’t

Franchise agreements carry specific disclosure requirements, including a disclosure document that must be provided within a fixed period before signature — a step that gets skipped or rushed more often than it should. Termination and renewal rights are the other area worth close attention on either side of a franchise transaction.

A practical way to use this

If a sale, fundraise or exit is realistically 12 to 24 months out, the highest-value move now is a readiness review — housekeeping, employment, IP, governance, and founder dependency — while there’s still time to fix what it finds, rather than disclose it under deal pressure.

Bottom line: founders rarely lose value in the room. They lose it in the months before, when the fundamentals above didn’t have a ready answer and the buyer’s lawyers were the ones who found that out first.

latest news & ARTICLES

Get in touch

"*" indicates required fields

Subscribe to our free quarterly newsletter*
Optimized by Optimole

Caveat's ai attorney,

ASK KAI

Ask our AI a question about this topic, and one of our specialist lawyers will review the response and email you within 24 hours, free of charge.

KAI is free for Caveat friends and clients. To use KAI, complete the form below and look out for the AI’s answer, reviewed by a specialist lawyer, in your inbox. For the most accurate and helpful response, be as specific and detailed as possible. Provide all relevant facts and clearly state what you’d like answered.

Disclaimer: Kai is provided by Caveat in a bona fide attempt to make legal services more accessible to you. Caveat will not be liable for any damage, loss or expense arising from the use of this offering. 

Feedback Welcome: Your experience matters to us. Please share feedback on this offering at info@caveatlegal.com to help us improve its efficacy.

Caveat's ai attorney,

ASK KAI

Ask our AI a question about this topic, and one of our specialist lawyers will review the response and email you within 24 hours, free of charge.

KAI is free for Caveat friends and clients. To use KAI, complete the form below and look out for the AI’s answer, reviewed by a specialist lawyer, in your inbox. For the most accurate and helpful response, be as specific and detailed as possible. Provide all relevant facts and clearly state what you’d like answered.

Disclaimer: Kai is provided by Caveat in a bona fide attempt to make legal services more accessible to you. Caveat will not be liable for any damage, loss or expense arising from the use of this offering. 

Feedback Welcome: Your experience matters to us. Please share feedback on this offering at info@caveatlegal.com to help us improve its efficacy.